by Kale » Wed Mar 28, 2018 7:16 am
I believe that quest requires you to have the max persuasion score that was possible in LF1. (45 base, +24 from Gable Cigar, bringing it to 69 total!) It’s very easy to miss the persuasion increases back in chapter 3, because they are limited time rewards.
You should double check that you do have the Gable Cigar equipped, just in case. If that isn’t enough, you can either replay chapter 3 and make sure you get every persuasion bonus this go around. Or come back in LF2 after you get the Duke Monocle, which raises your persuasion even more.